You are here: Your Questions

Orange in Winter Colour Palette?

by Linda

I think I am a Winter Colour Palette - having been colour coded many years ago. My hair is dark brown with grey, looks like I streaked it. My complexion is pale in winter, but I lightly tan (yellow) in summer. When I wear orange I get a lot of complements. How can this be for a Winter? I also have been told I look great in chocolate brown, golden yellow and royal blue, but I look awful in khaki. Am I a Winter or something else?

Jane's answer...Great question Linda! My short answers are:

  • No, orange is not in the Winter colour palette! Orange is a warm colour best worn by those with Spring or Autumn colouring. Although there are ways to bend the 'rules' that can make orange work for other colour categories as well (more on this below), if someone really wants to wear orange

  • I can't tell from this photo whether your colouring is Winter or something else. Partly, because I don't know whether you used a flash when this photo was taken. Partly, because the photo is too small. For an online colour analysis I give very specific guidelines for taking photos and I also use a questionnaire to help inform my decision

Since you say you were colour coded many years ago I suspect it was when coding placed each person into one of just 4 colour categories (named after the seasons to help remember them better). After a while of using 4 seasonal colour coding it became obvious that the system was too restrictive and didn't work well for everyone. Now-a-days Image Consultants typically use a 12, 14 or 16 category system. Many of these contemporary systems are still based on the underlying 4 seasonal method, but recognise that a person can be a mix of colour categories.

It used to be thought that once you had been colour coded, that was your colouring for life. We now know that isn't true. As we age our hair, skin and eyes fade. And, even if we colour our hair, we may eventually change colour categories within a season and even change from one season to another. So, if you're finding the clear Winter colours are not working for you, this may be what's going on. However, I don't believe it's possible to go from being a cool based colouring to a warm based one, unless you were incorrectly coded the first time. Or, it could be, with only 4 categories to place you in, that the Winter classification was the most appropriate at the time.

The colour of your jacket in the photo looks to be a warm, medium brown, also not a Winter colour, yet it seems to echo the warm browns in your skin, hair and eyes, so it doesn't look wrong. However, bear in mind that you can have some warmth about your look without being in a warm colour category.

Have a look at the virtual drapes I've used in the pictures above. Bear in mind that each of these 3 photos is identical, except for the colours displayed under them. This is what I see:
  • Orange (this one is warm and muted) makes your skin look too orange (it also makes your eyes look smaller)

  • Fuschia pink (cool and clear) makes you look radiant, although that particular colour looks a bit too bright for you (I see the colour before I see you)

  • Olive green (warm and muted) actually looks quite good on you -- the colour is maybe a touch too warm, but the colour value (how light or dark) and intensity (how vivid or dull) look correct

So in the photo you've provided I see you as most likely having a cool skin undertone, but with some warmth to your skin overtone and hair colour, meaning you could be one of the Winter colour seasons or a Soft Summer (cool, muted and soft).

Bending the colour 'rules'

If you really want to wear a colour that isn't your best colour here as some ways to do it:
  • Wear the colour away from your face -- it is what you wear from your bust up that matters most for colours, since this is what someone looking at you sees when they look at your face and because a colour that isn't your best will detract from your colouring in some way. For instance, it may make your skin look too yellow, too grey, or too pale

  • Minimise the amount of the wrong colour near your face -- for example if the item has a deeper, wider neckline, no straps, or thin straps we'll see more of your skin and less of the wrong colour reflecting on your face

  • Layer the wrong colour with items in your best colours -- for example wear a jacket, or cardigan over the wrong colour. Or layer a top under the wrong item. Or wear a necklace that includes a majority of your most flattering colours

  • Make sure the wrong colour is a medium colour value -- not too light or too dark and not too vivd or too dull. This will lessen the effect of the wrong colour

Colour analysis services

If you would like a full colours analysis make use of my online colour analysis service, see the details here. I'd love to help you work this out! For those of you in Sydney come and have your colours done in person.

Related pages

For more on colour see the following articles:

Comments for Orange in Winter Colour Palette?

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Response to 'Clear Winter'
by: Jane of Style Makeover HQ

Yes, absolutely! Wearing a scarf is another way to layer and make a 'wrong' colour work better.

And thanks so much for describing what's going on with you and colours.

Sometimes, we just have to follow our instincts and wear the colours that are calling us, even if they aren't supposed to be right for us.

It could be that your body needs the energy of that colour at the moment? A quick Google for orange and chakra shows that orange is associated with sexuality, creativity, desire, compassion and the reproductive system.

And yes, sometimes there's a disconnect between our personality and our colouring.

Other ways to wear a 'wrong' colour are:
  • Choose a pattern with a small amount of the colour you crave in it

  • Wear underwear in that colour

And yes, home decor items in your favourite colours are a great idea ;D

Which shades of orange for CLEAR WINTERS, please?
by: Clear Winter

You forgot to say "WEAR A SCARF in a matching winter shade"!

That said, there has to be a shade of orange that looks great on us. I'm a CLEAR WINTER. Dark orange (bright with more red than yellow, like the pantone for... 2018 was it?) is horrible on me. So is the skin-orange shade. I'm thinking about something with more yellow. I am in love with apricot (items, color online or on TV stars) but I have yet to come across a clothing item that I could try near my face. I adore all shades that are very wrong for me (lavender and all pastels) I look catapulted into those clothes.

I loathe navy but it has become the so-called "go-to" color after my soft black hair turned gray, and I no longer feel like wearing my trustee black, in which I looked beyond fabulous. Navy provides the same brightness to my complexion. I bought slate blue towels and regretted it when I saw how drab I looked in the mirror when wrapped in one.

After decades of HATING pink, I received a garment that is spectacular on me in pink. Sadly, I'm unable to find more. It's pastel-ish but bright, not soft. I also look great in fuchsia (aka hot pink) but I don't have the attention-commanding personality for it. I am more of a wallflower, blend in the dark, type.

That said, I am so drawn to orange lately, a color I have always loathed. So what to do? I just done cruising the Google IMages asking "what shade of orange for clear winters" and there's no returns, no matter how many keywords I stripped that of to leave on the 3.

Why did I have to have a wallflower personality with my coloring?! *sighs* I should have been a pale blonde blue eyed girl. (I'm very pale, can't tan, hazel eyes.) When I can afford frivolous stuff, I'll order fabric samples in different shades of yellow-orange. Maybe butternut squash (the inside) will flatter me? I hope. Otherwise, it's decor items in my favorite oranges. I'm ordering sunglasses soon. Thanks for reading.

Pleased I could help
by: Jane of Style Makeover HQ

Hi Zoe, you're welcome! Pleased that makes sense to you,

Some color systems have 14 or more categories, but I find the 12 category flow seasonal system that I use works really well.

At last!
by: Zoe

Hello, Jane!
I just read what you have written, that there are more than the four season color palettes and I want to thank you soooo much!
I have been trying so hard to include a friend of mine in one of those four and she just couldn't be anywhere! And now it's clear to me!
I owe you big!
Zoe, Greece

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Style Makeover Question.

Like This Page?

About Me

jane liddelow

"Your style makeover may require a few tweaks or a total re-think. Using a mix of science and art I show you how to discover your style and look great every day.

Hi, I'm Jane Liddelow, the Personal Image Consultant and Stylist responsible for this site. Find out more about me here."

Style Snippets